Two Thieves Bound
by Honor Ricochet Through the Underworld
By A. O. SCOTT Claude
Sautet's "Classe Tous Risques"
is the kind of French movie that makes you
want to throw on your trench coat, light up
a cigarette and shoot somebody. Originally
released in 1960, it was lost in the frenzy
of the Nouvelle Vague, which made its straightforward
use of genre look a bit old-fashioned. Back
then, a dubbed version (titled "The Big
Risk" and distributed by United Artists)
played briefly in American theaters, but now,
thanks to Rialto Pictures, English speakers
can see a handsome restored print with newly
translated subtitles. It is worth seeking out,
not only because "Classe Tous Risques"
represents a missing piece of film history
- a link between the great postwar policiers
and the brooding 1960's gangster dramas of
Jean-Pierre Melville - but because it is a
tough and touching exploration of honor and
friendship among thieves.
Mr. Sautet, who died in 2000, is better
known for delicate psychological dramas
like "A Heart in Winter" (1992) and
"Nelly and Mr. Arnaud" (1995), which
would appear, at first glance, to have little
in common with this underworld chronicle. But
as the lean, efficiently linear plot unfolds,
nuances of feeling and motivation seem to collect
between the lines and around the edges of the
frame. The story, adapted from a novel by José
Giovanni, begins in Milan, where Abel Davos
(Lino Ventura), an exiled French mobster, is
about to return home with his wife, his two
young sons and his partner, Raymond Naldi (Stan
Krol). After putting the wife and kids on a
train to Ventimiglia, Davos and Naldi commit
a robbery on a city street in broad daylight,
and then head for France in a series of stolen
cars, a bus and a commandeered pleasure boat.
But the jauntiness of this adventure is
shadowed by a sense of sadness and fatigue,
borne out in a sudden eruption of lethal violence.
The heaviness of Davos's situation seems to
reside in Mr. Ventura's meaty, rough-hewn face
and solid frame. His size and strength make
him curiously vulnerable, and before long he
finds a perfect foil in the silky, slender
person of Jean-Paul Belmondo. Mr. Belmondo,
amazingly youthful and on the cusp of international
stardom, plays Eric Stark, a freelancer dispatched
by Davos's Parisian buddies to escort their
long-lost comrade from Nice to Paris.
The sending of a surrogate to fulfill their
obligations turns out to be the film's
moral crux. Davos's old friends are for various
reasons disinclined to risk their own safety
to help him, a caution he regards as a mortal
betrayal. Stark's instincts are more generous,
and he and Davos form a friendship founded
on a shared code. Their bond is conveyed through
exquisite understatement on the part of both
the actors and the director. These are not
the kind of guys who go around hugging each
other, which makes their evident love all the
more poignant. (The manly chastity of this
affection is guaranteed by Liliane, an itinerant
actress who falls for Stark, and who is played,
with luscious irrelevance, by Sandra Milo.)
The relationship of these two men turns
the movie, which never departs from the
conventions of its genre, toward a rough, matter-of-fact
profundity. It ends cleanly, almost with a
shrug, but leaves you pondering the nature
of loyalty, obligation and revenge. Mr. Ventura
and Mr. Belmondo would go on to play tough
guys and seducers of various kinds, but there
is something especially rare and fine about
this collaboration, in which the tough guys,
without acknowledging as much, in effect seduce
each other.
Classe Tous Risques
Directed by Claude
Sautet; written (in French and Italian, with
English subtitles) by Mr. Sautet, José
Giovanni and Pascal Jardin, based on the novel
by Mr. Giovanni; director of photography, Ghislain
Cloquet; edited by Albert Jurgenson; music
by Georges Delerue; produced by Jean Darvey;
released by Rialto Pictures. Running time:
103 minutes. This film is not rated.
WITH: Lino Ventura (Abel Davos), Jean-Paul
Belmondo (Eric Stark), Sandra Milo (Liliane),
Marcel Dalio(Arthur
Gibelin), Michel Ardan (Riton Vintran), Stan
Krol (Raymond Naldi) and Claude Cerval (Raoul
Fargier).
|